By Matthew Wheaton
No trip to downtown Galesburg circa 1890 would be complete without a stop by O.T. Johnson’s or Kellogg, Drake & Company. Those locally owned department stores led the way for the Crandell’s, Ward’s and Bergner’s stores that would come and go after them.
Galesburg resident Julie Kellogg laments the passing of the downtown department stores. “I would like to see some bigger department stores downtown. Something to mimic the Shoppes of Grand Prairie but on a smaller scale,” she said.
Galesburg’s first downtown department store survived 118 years, bearing the name of a founder who left town before the turn of the 20th century.
In 1860, O.T. Johnson moved to town from Altona, Ill. Shortly after, he bought out his employers, Sage and Reed, and started a small general store, located at 125 East Main Street, which he named after himself.
Johnson’s store grew gradually, while he planned to move to California. So in 1890, he let Robert Chappell take over the day-to-day operations.
O.T. Johnson’s could “claim the distinction of being the largest general department store in the country, to be located in a city the size of Galesburg,” according to a December 11, 1903 article published in the Daily Republican-Register.
In 1909, Chappell released plans to build a new store in the same location as the old one. The new building was erected in two phases so O.T.’s could stay open during construction. The total cost of the project was $50,000 and J. Grant Beadle was the architect. O.T. Johnson’s remained a staple of downtown until 1978.
“O.T. Johnson’s was the place to go downtown,” local historian Tom Wilson said. “It was one of the first department stores downtown. Others started picking up after the turn of the century. Every type of thing you could imagine was sold inside O.T’s. They sold everything but cars.”
Just before Chappell took over O.T.’s, the store acquired some competition.
On October 12, 1889, Kellogg, Drake & Company, owned by Harvey E. Kellogg, E.R. Drake, Alfred Olson and a man by the last name of Nelson, opened for business in a small storeroom in the Union Hotel.
Kellogg, Drake & Company moved from the small storeroom to 227, 229 and 231 East Main, where the Main Street Mall is today, on January 1, 1890. The new location provided three floors for the businessmen to sell their goods.
In the new locations Kellogg, Drake & Company carried “not only a large stock of dry goods and cloaks, but also one of the largest stocks of carpets in the region,” according to an October 7, 1899 article published in the Daily Republican-Register.
In January 1966, a $250,000 going out of business sale took place at Kellogg, Drake & Company, because the owners decided to retire.
Kellogg, Drake & Company along with O.T. Johnson’s seem to be the only two department stores in downtown Galesburg before the turn of the century. However, many came after.